FSHD1 vs FSHD2 – what’s the difference?

Written by

in

When I finally received my diagnosis, it wasn’t simply FSHD. It was FSHD Type 2.

That distinction turned out to be rather important. I’d been tested for FSHD before without getting the answer we were looking for.

So what’s the difference between FSHD1 and FSHD2?

The simplest answer is that they are two different genetic routes to essentially the same problem.

1. Same condition, two different routes

FSHD1 and FSHD2 aren’t two completely different diseases.

People with either type can experience the same characteristic patterns of muscle weakness, and from a clinical point of view they can be extremely difficult to distinguish from one another.

The difference is mainly in why it happens. There are two different genetic routes that can lead to the same important thing happening inside muscle cells. And at the centre of both is something called DUX4.

2. The switch that should stay off

We all have the DUX4 gene. Having it isn’t the problem. In most adult tissues, including skeletal muscle, DUX4 is normally kept tightly switched off.

You can think of part of our DNA as having a sophisticated locking system that helps keep it that way. In FSHD, that locking system isn’t working as it should.

The result is that DUX4 can become active in muscle cells where it shouldn’t be, setting off processes that can damage those cells.

3. FSHD Type 1

FSHD1 is by far the more common form, accounting for roughly 95% of FSHD. There’s a repeated section of DNA near the end of chromosome 4 called D4Z4.

Normally there are many copies of this repeated section. In FSHD1, the D4Z4 region on a disease-permissive chromosome is unusually short — often described as a contraction.

That change makes it harder for the body to keep the region tightly locked down. And ultimately, DUX4 can get switched on.

4. FSHD Type 2

FSHD2 takes a different route.

The D4Z4 region isn’t shortened in the same way as it is in FSHD1. Instead, the problem usually involves another gene called SMCHD1.

One of SMCHD1’s jobs is to help maintain the tightly packed, silenced state around D4Z4.

If SMCHD1 isn’t doing that job properly, the DNA can become more loosely controlled — or hypomethylated — and again DUX4 can escape its normal suppression. There are rarer genetic causes of FSHD2 too, but SMCHD1 is the most common.

That’s the route that eventually led to my diagnosis.

5. Different cause. Similar result.

This is the bit that made the whole thing click for me. FSHD1: the D4Z4 region is contracted.

FSHD2: the machinery helping to keep that region switched off isn’t working properly.

Different routes, but both can lead to the same destination: DUX4 becoming active in muscle cells when it shouldn’t be.

Which also explains why someone with FSHD1 and someone with FSHD2 can have very similar symptoms.

6. Why this mattered to me

This isn’t just an interesting bit of genetics for me. It’s an important part of my story.

I’d undergone testing for FSHD earlier in my diagnostic journey without receiving an FSHD diagnosis. Eventually, further genetic investigation found a variant in my SMCHD1 gene and subsequent testing showed the severe hypomethylation consistent with FSHD2.

Suddenly, the distinction between Type 1 and Type 2 wasn’t academic at all. It was the reason that something could appear to have been tested for — and yet the answer was still waiting to be found.

For me, the difference between FSHD1 and FSHD2 was the difference between a negative test and finally having an answer.

A single-page version

If you’d prefer the whole explanation on one page, you can download/save the infographic below.